The Case of the Impossible Chronicler

Keeping the Canon

The Case of the Impossible Chronicler is written to be read against the sixty stories. It changes nothing Dr Watson published.

The three years

On 4 May 1891 Sherlock Holmes went over the Reichenbach Falls, or so Dr Watson told the world in “The Final Problem”. In the spring of 1894, in “The Empty House”, he walked back into Watson’s life and gave his friend a short account of where he had been. Between those two stories lie three years the Canon never shows. Sherlockians call them the Great Hiatus.

The trilogy is set inside those years, on the North York Moors. Everything Watson published stays true, and “The Empty House” stays possible to the day.

Watson’s accounts, on their dates

In the books, as in the world, Dr Watson’s accounts reach the public on their real dates. The Strand Magazine, new in January 1891, printed the Adventures one a month from July 1891 to June 1892, and the Memoirs from December 1892 until “The Final Problem” in the December number of 1893. A moor village had its magazine by post, a month at a time.

The untold cases of 1894

Opening “The Golden Pince-Nez”, Watson looks over his notes for 1894 and names cases he never wrote up:

As I turn over the pages, I see my notes upon the repulsive story of the red leech and the terrible death of Crosby, the banker. Here also I find an account of the Addleton tragedy, and the singular contents of the ancient British barrow. The famous Smith-Mortimer succession case comes also within this period, and so does the tracking and arrest of Huret, the Boulevard assassin.

Dr Watson's Casebook of the Return tells four of them, the Addleton tragedy, the barrow, the Smith-Mortimer succession and Huret, in Watson’s own voice, with every clue on the page before Holmes explains it. The red leech and Crosby the banker are left to him.

Notes on the period

Certifying a man, 1891

Under the Lunacy Act of 1890 a private patient was ordinarily confined on a petition, an order from a justice of the peace and two medical certificates. Each certificate asked its doctor to set down the facts indicating insanity observed by himself, and to sign. The North Riding’s county asylum stood at Clifton, outside York.

The inquest

Any sudden or suspicious death went to the coroner within days. In a village the inquest sat with a jury in the largest room to hand, often at the inn. Witnesses gave evidence on oath, the coroner might adjourn for a post-mortem, and the jury’s verdict could name a man and send him for trial.

No fingerprints yet

No English police force identified anyone by fingerprints in 1891. Francis Galton’s book on them came out in 1892, and Scotland Yard’s fingerprint bureau not until 1901. A print in snow or mud was read the old way, by its size, its nails and its stride.